Other Titles
Symposium: HIV and Intimate Partner Violence: Risks and Relationships Among Women
Abstract
Session presented on Monday, July 25, 2016:
Purpose: The United States Virgin Islands (USVI) has the 2nd highest HIV/AIDS incidence rate in the United States and its territories (US Virgin Islands, 2010). Additionally, one-third of USVI women reports physical and/or sexual abuse in their lifetime and experiences of coercive, unprotected sex and other behaviors that increase risks for HIV/AIDS (Draughon JE1, 2015; Stockman JK, 2013; Stockman, 2014). There is scant research that aims to understand USVI women and men's perceptions of heterosexual relationship dynamics or implications for HIV/AIDS risks and intimate partner violence. The purpose of this study was to describe young heterosexual women and men's attitudes and behaviors toward relationship conflict and sexual activities in the USVI.
Methods: Qualitative methods using focus group discussions were employed to elicit participants' attitudes and perceptions. Women and men from the US Virgin Islands of St. Thomas and St. Croix were recruited to participate in the groups. We held one focus group of women on each Island and separate focus groups of men on each Island. The focus group objectives were to elicit information about intimate partner abuse and sexual health risks among men and women in the USVI. Interviews were conducted with small groups (4-8) by gender after participants were consented and signed confidentiality pledges. We performed directed content analysis of transcripts and uncovered separate themes from both the women and men's groups.
Results: Themes underlying attitudes, perceptions and experiences of partner abuse identified by women emerged and included 1) Female vulnerability and male dominance/control in relationships 2) Perceptions of community silence on topic of partner abuse and stigmatization 3) Lack of community resources and 4) Resistance to safe sexual practices by abusive partners and increased STI/HIV risks. Male participants in the focus groups identified themes related to 1) Upholding gender expectations; 2) Fearing loss of control; and 3) Deflecting responsibilities. Male participants described attitudes as underpinnings to subsequent violent responses and sexual behavior decisions. These findings demonstrate the complex ways culturally-framed norms intersect with sexual health behaviors. The USVI is unique due to its position as a U.S. territory infused with the cultural expectations of a Caribbean island.
Conclusion: Results from this qualitative research provided the basis for our researchers and practitioners to develop a culturally sensitive intimate partner violence empowerment program for abused African Caribbean women in the USVI. Using concepts of culture and context we adapted intervention materials to the USVI context that have been used successfully with abused women of African American and/or Hispanic origin in mainland USA settings but not yet in the US Virgin Islands. The interventions include a previously developed and tested structured IPV intervention Domestic Violence Enhanced Home Visitation (DOVE), (Bhandari S, 2015) and the well validated culturally sensitive Sister-to-Sister skills intervention to reduce sex risk behaviors and prevent new STD infections (Jemmott LS, 2007).
Sigma Membership
Non-member
Type
Presentation
Format Type
Text-based Document
Study Design/Type
N/A
Research Approach
N/A
Keywords:
GBV/Partner Violence, HIV/AIDS Risk Violent Relationships, Attitude, Behaviors GBV
Recommended Citation
Campbell, Doris W.; Campbell, Jacquelyn C.; Alexander, Kamila A.; Callwood, Gloria B.; Bertrand, Desiree; Sharps, Phyllis; and St. Vil, Noelle M., "Attitudes and behaviors of Caribbean women and men toward partner violence and sexual relationships" (2016). INRC (Congress). 189.
https://www.sigmarepository.org/inrc/2016/presentations_2016/189
Conference Name
27th International Nursing Research Congress
Conference Host
Sigma Theta Tau International
Conference Location
Cape Town, South Africa
Conference Year
2016
Rights Holder
All rights reserved by the author(s) and/or publisher(s) listed in this item record unless relinquished in whole or part by a rights notation or a Creative Commons License present in this item record.
All permission requests should be directed accordingly and not to the Sigma Repository.
All submitting authors or publishers have affirmed that when using material in their work where they do not own copyright, they have obtained permission of the copyright holder prior to submission and the rights holder has been acknowledged as necessary.
Review Type
Abstract Review Only: Reviewed by Event Host
Acquisition
Proxy-submission
Attitudes and behaviors of Caribbean women and men toward partner violence and sexual relationships
Cape Town, South Africa
Session presented on Monday, July 25, 2016:
Purpose: The United States Virgin Islands (USVI) has the 2nd highest HIV/AIDS incidence rate in the United States and its territories (US Virgin Islands, 2010). Additionally, one-third of USVI women reports physical and/or sexual abuse in their lifetime and experiences of coercive, unprotected sex and other behaviors that increase risks for HIV/AIDS (Draughon JE1, 2015; Stockman JK, 2013; Stockman, 2014). There is scant research that aims to understand USVI women and men's perceptions of heterosexual relationship dynamics or implications for HIV/AIDS risks and intimate partner violence. The purpose of this study was to describe young heterosexual women and men's attitudes and behaviors toward relationship conflict and sexual activities in the USVI.
Methods: Qualitative methods using focus group discussions were employed to elicit participants' attitudes and perceptions. Women and men from the US Virgin Islands of St. Thomas and St. Croix were recruited to participate in the groups. We held one focus group of women on each Island and separate focus groups of men on each Island. The focus group objectives were to elicit information about intimate partner abuse and sexual health risks among men and women in the USVI. Interviews were conducted with small groups (4-8) by gender after participants were consented and signed confidentiality pledges. We performed directed content analysis of transcripts and uncovered separate themes from both the women and men's groups.
Results: Themes underlying attitudes, perceptions and experiences of partner abuse identified by women emerged and included 1) Female vulnerability and male dominance/control in relationships 2) Perceptions of community silence on topic of partner abuse and stigmatization 3) Lack of community resources and 4) Resistance to safe sexual practices by abusive partners and increased STI/HIV risks. Male participants in the focus groups identified themes related to 1) Upholding gender expectations; 2) Fearing loss of control; and 3) Deflecting responsibilities. Male participants described attitudes as underpinnings to subsequent violent responses and sexual behavior decisions. These findings demonstrate the complex ways culturally-framed norms intersect with sexual health behaviors. The USVI is unique due to its position as a U.S. territory infused with the cultural expectations of a Caribbean island.
Conclusion: Results from this qualitative research provided the basis for our researchers and practitioners to develop a culturally sensitive intimate partner violence empowerment program for abused African Caribbean women in the USVI. Using concepts of culture and context we adapted intervention materials to the USVI context that have been used successfully with abused women of African American and/or Hispanic origin in mainland USA settings but not yet in the US Virgin Islands. The interventions include a previously developed and tested structured IPV intervention Domestic Violence Enhanced Home Visitation (DOVE), (Bhandari S, 2015) and the well validated culturally sensitive Sister-to-Sister skills intervention to reduce sex risk behaviors and prevent new STD infections (Jemmott LS, 2007).